The next section presents the trends in growth and inequality and makes some important observations regarding the shortcomings of the kuznets curve. Wars increased inequality but had nonpermanent effects, while progressive taxation had no impact until 1980, at odds with. How urbanization affects the inequality in developing. Ekcrelated studies started with simon kuznets 1955 who examined the relationship between income inequality and economic growth. According to the kuznets s u curve theory, urbanization increases inequality in developing countries during the first phase of industrialization. The rise and fall of the environmental kuznets curve david i. Pdf inequality, poverty and the kuznets curve in spain. Income inequality and economic growththe kuznets curve. Emissions of various pollutants, such as carbon dioxide, sulfur, and nitrogen oxides, are tightly coupled to the use of energy. A russianamerican economist and statistician who won the 1971 nobel memorial prize in economic sciences for his research on economic growth.
In an empirical part the paper shows with newer data that a signi cant inequality based kuznets curve exists for the case of brazil and that the level of gdp alone can explain most of the ariationv in inequalit. Pdf this paper describes global trends in average educational attainment and in education inequality since 1870, improving the database released by. Stern department of economics, rensselaer polytechnic institute, troy, ny 12180, usa june 2003 1. The hypothesis was first advanced by economist simon kuznets in the 1950s and 1960s. The only evidence that appears to support the kuznets hypothesis is the cross sectional pattern of inequality levels across countries, although the. Simon kuznets put forward the hypothesis that relationship between per capita national income and the degree of inequality in income distribution may be of the form of invertedu. It would seem that he was reasonably correct as well. This paper presents a critical history of the environmental kuznets curve ekc.
The environmental kuznets curve ekc is one of the crucial energyenvironmental economics research fields, which has been attracted by numerous academics and researchers for the last three decades. The environmental kuznets curve is used to graph the idea that as an economy develops, market forces begin to increase and economic inequality decreases. The kuznets curve simon kuznets 1955, was first used to describe the progression of economic inequality as countries develop. James van alstine and eric neumayer the environmental kuznets. The third section presents the econometric model adopted to explain this rise inequality. He found that this ratio kuznets ratio for india, sri lanka and. James van alstine and eric neumayer the environmental. It demonstrates that kuznets famous invertedu shape relationship between inequality and economic growth will holdthe growth rate will be first increasing with the income inequality before the growth rate decreases with inequality. It argues that kuznets 1955 paper stands the test of time in that it provides illuminating insights into current phenomena like the evolution of chinese inequality. Merits and limitations of kuznets curve research papers. Stern rensselaer polytechnic institute, troy, ny, usa available online summary. Environmental kuznets curve an overview sciencedirect topics. Analyzing the relationship between income inequality and.
This paper tests for the existence of a health kuznets curve. Apr 12, 2017 the curve is known after economist simon kuznets who made a wellknown study about the relationship between inequality and economic development. The kuznets curve hypothesis posits that initially, at lower levels of. The kuznets hypothesis suggests that inequality is low at a lower income level but later increases at higher income level with economic growth. And, outlined successful growth and development is contingent on the presence of important. More specifically that as the economy grows, initially the environment suffers but eventually the relationship between the environment and the society improves. The hypothesis states that at very low levels of income, income inequality must also be low, as practically everybody lives at, or close to, subsistence level. Regression results for income inequality kuznets curves 10 4. The empirical validity of this kuznets curve has been intensively inves. Among his several observations which sparked important theoretical research programs was the kuznets curve, an inverted ushaped relation between income inequality and economic growth 1955, 1963. Inequality, poverty and the kuznets curve in spain, 18502000.
Analyzing the relationship between income inequality and economic growth. Economic growth and income inequality 3 groups that, judged by their secular levels, migrate upward or down ward on the income scale. Inequality in years of schooling is shown to have mechanically decreased along with the decline in the share of illiterate people. Much of this literature sought to test the environmental kuznets curve ekc hypothesis, which posits that in the early stages of economic development environmental degradation will increase until a certain level of income is reached known as the turning point and then environmental improvement will occur. In that study also, the relationship between inequality and economic development gives an inverted u shape. Kuznets started with some basic and fundamental questions, does inequality in the distribution of income increase or decrease in the course of a countrys economic growth. How urbanization affects the inequality in developing countries. There is no room for increased inequality because kuznets curve and the inequality process. View merits and limitations of kuznets curve research papers on academia.
This paper shows that the iconic kuznets curve can be derived from the inequality process ip, a conservative particle system, presenting a counterexample to gallegati et al. A fundamental issue facing the global economy is the widening poverty gap between the developed and less developed world, and the widening distribution of income within countries and geographical regions. Kuznets inverted uhypothesis on income inequality economics. The environmental kuznets curve intelligent economist. In a seminal paper, kuznets 1955 argued that as countries developed, income inequality. Mar 30, 2018 how might inequality be affected by income growth. The hypothesis was first advanced by economist simon kuznets in the 1950s and 1960s one explanation of such a progression suggests that early in development, investment opportunities for those who have money multiply. The kuznets curve is the graph of income inequality ordinate variable against the movement of workers from rural subsistence agriculture into more modern. We find a robust invertedu relationship between income inequality and political development, but not one between income inequality and economic development.
The concept of the environmental kuznets curve ekc is not that helpful in explaining the negative correlation between inequality and environmental quality. Two major trends in inequality have characterized industrial and developing societies in the twentieth century. In his seminal paper, which kuznets presented while. In the era of freetrade, it is expected that economic inequality reduces and more growth is achieved on account of knowledge and technology transfer from the developed to developing nations. It describes the finding that inequality first increases and then decreases. One of the major stylized facts about longrun processes of economic development is the kuznets curvethe inverseu shaped pattern of inequality. Economic rather than political forces appear to dominate inequality trends in spain.
Introduction the environmental kuznets curve is a hypothesized relationship between various indicators of environmental degradation and income per capita. Much of this literature sought to test the environmental kuznets curve ekc hypothesis, which posits that in the early stages of economic. China a country example of the kuznets curve in the making. Jun 29, 2012 within countries, we find evidence of an inverted ushape curve for human capital inequality over time, namely a kuznets curve for human capital. Barro 1999 has recently showed that a greater inequality can have a dierential impact. A look at kuznets ushaped inequality curve tells the story. Within countries, we find evidence of an inverted ushape curve for human capital inequality over time, namely a kuznets curve for human capital.
The relationship between income inequality and economic development has popularly been characterized by the kuznets invertedu curve kuznets, 1955, which argued that income inequality tends to increase at an initial stage of development and then decrease as the economy develops, implying that income inequality will fall as income continues. Given the close linkage between human capital and income, the. Though with respect to findings and analysis there is no common consensus to support or reject the inverted u hypothesis, but in its own sphere it became the base for carrying forward the. Mar 14, 2014 whether the chinese government can change their attitude towards inequality and economic development is bound to have a considerable effect on whether china can reduce inequality and undergo the second half of the kuznets curve. Inequality, poverty and the kuznets curve in spain, 1850. An example of an estimated environmental kuznets curve ekc is shown in fig. The kuznets curve and the inequality process munich. Due to limitations of data he used an inequality measure of the ratio of income share of the richest 20 per cent of the population to the bottom 60 per cent of the population known as kuznets ratio.
At low levels of income, countries may exhibit traditional industries such as subsistence farming which generates low levels of inequality. According to the kuznetss ucurve theory, urbanization increases inequality in developing countries during the first phase of industrialization. At the global level, the world inequality in human capital has followed a similar trajectory, first increasing from 1870 to 1970, then decreasing. Secondly, our findings can resolve the human capital kuznets curve puzzle in the literature. The ushaped pattern shows up strongly in a nonparametric trend, in stochastic kernel estimation, but weakly in a quadratic fixed effect trend. The rise and fall of the environmental kuznets curve. In a nutshell, the hypothesis simply states that income inequality should follow an inverseu shape along the development process. Grossman and krueger 1995 and the world bank 1992 first popularized this idea, using a simple empirical approach. China a country example of the kuznets curve in the. Environmental kuznets curve an overview sciencedirect. Kuznets inverted u hypothesis of income inequality. The hypothesis states that at very low levels of income, income inequality must also be low, as practically. Through decades of trial and error, economist and researchers realize the mechanics of development as intertwined with growth, inequality, and poverty.
Thus the relationship between income distribution and income level can be described by an inverted u curve. There is no room for increased inequality because kuznets curve david i. This paper explores the question of structural transformation and income distribution through the eyes of simon kuznets, the pioneer in such analysis. What factors determine the secular level and trends of income inequalities. Cohort size, kuznets curves, and openness by matthew higgins federal reserve bank of new york and jeffrey g. The kuznets curve and inequality jhu economics johns. The ekc is named for simon kuznets, who hypothesized that income in equality. Mar 01, 2018 the environmental kuznets curve is used to graph the idea that as an economy develops, market forces begin to increase and economic inequality decreases. Prioritizing growth over welfare spending a kuznets u. The kuznets curve is concave down and skewed to the right. Economic growth and income inequality gabriel zucman.
Pdf the kuznets curve and the inequality process researchgate. In the 1950s and 1960s, simon kuznets hypothesized that as an economy develops, market forces first increase then decrease the overall economic inequality of the society, which is illustrated by the inverted ushape of the kuznets curve. Wars increased inequality but had nonpermanent effects, while progressive taxation had no impact until 1980, at odds with atkinson, piketty, saez and associates findings. This paper examines two closely related empirical hypotheses. An altemative hypothesis to country income inequality. Sep 27, 2009 4197 the kuznets curve and inequality simon kuznets predicted that as an economy develops inequality will rise and then, at a certain stage of development naturally begin to fall back again. Williamson harvard university june 1999 the authors can be reached at the following email addresses. The kuznets curve and inequality adam smith institute.
In his classic paper, kuznets 1955 suggests that inequality increases as average income rises from a low level but then, at a critical point, begins to decrease as average income rises further. James van alstine and eric neumayer the environmental kuznets curve. Ekcrelated studies started with simon kuznets 1955 who examined the relationship between income inequality and economic. Effect of income inequality on economic growth 12 3. Finally, a conclusive paragraph highlights the need for further research and the contribution this paper makes to the ongoing debate on inequality. The kuznets curve hypothesis has been one of the most debated issues in development economics since the mid1950s. Even if we had data to approximate the income structure just out lined, the broad question posed at the starthow income inequality changes in the process of a countrys economic growthcould be. Introduction the relationship between income disparity and economic growth has been a critical issue in macroeconomics over several decades. Observed by simon kuznets in 1955, the kuznets curve predicts that inequality within a country will follow a determined path as it develops. Apr 10, 2019 in the 1950s and 1960s, simon kuznets hypothesized that as an economy develops, market forces first increase then decrease the overall economic inequality of the society, which is illustrated by the inverted ushape of the kuznets curve. Feb 14, 20 observed by simon kuznets in 1955, the kuznets curve predicts that inequality within a country will follow a determined path as it develops. Income inequality and the environmental kuznets curve. Subsequently, the kuznets curve has been applied to the evolution of pollution levels of countries through their development process.
1381 1458 1082 1250 1215 851 1172 1472 630 1287 1216 1626 1281 1323 948 1009 897 973 1316 246 535 1371 416 1166 991 996 1141 485 339 929 247 593 1092 102 1218 487 579 1192